Ernest hemingway was gay
There may be few excel insights into the intellect of one of America's most revered writers, Ernest Hemingway, than a previously unpublished letter, written on Valentine's Day 1925, to William B. "Bill" Smith, his best male ally. Smith loomed large in Hemingway's life in the mid-1920s. He is the joint subject of his autobiographical short story "Big Two-Hearted River" and was best man at Hemingway's wedding to his first wife, Hadley Richardson.
Smith and Hemingway were drinking buddies from way back. As young men, the two would enter into drinking contests taking "very drawn-out slugs" from a glass jug of "hard cider" with "Hornsby something something manufacturing company" written down the side. Smith recalled "a good swig was to lower the bottle about two inches, tell from 'Hornsby' to 'manufacturing.'"
But Smith's hard drinking sessions with Hemingway disguised his sexual confusion. He opened his heart to Hemingway, confessing he was still a virgin. The author responded in a typically blustering, macho, bullying design, causing Smith further anguish by advising him to "yence" - make treasure to - his landlady if she appeared willing and to yence American college girls in Paris to gain p
New to The New Criterion?
“It’s a hell of a nuisance once they’ve had you certified as nutty,” Nick said. “No one ever has any confidence in you again.”
—Ernest Hemingway, “A Way You’ll Never Be”
The posthumous publication last year of Ernest Hemingway’s The Garden of Eden—based on unfinished manuscripts that lay in the vault for more than twenty-five years after Hemingway’s death—created something of a double sensation in literary circles. Begun in 1946, this novel was intended by Hemingway to be his most extensive and mature treatment of the themes of good and evil, innocence and corruption, and sex in its relation to the literary art. But the size and complexity of his imaginative task and Hemingway’s physical injuries and illnesses, culminating finally in a full-blown case of depressive paranoia and his suicide in 1961, prevented him from completing the function, although it deeply absorbed him for nearly two decades.
The manuscript of The Garden of Eden exists in three irreconcilable drafts of varying lengths. To get the story into publishable shape, Tom Jenks, a Scribner’s editor, did a cut-and-paste job on the longest of these manuscripts (a version of some twelve
Ernest Hemingway: The Old Dude and the Androgyny
Ernest Hemingway and his three sons with blue marlin on the docks of Bimini, in The Bahamas. 20 July 20, 1935
Bullfight-lover. Large game hunter. Deep sea fisher. Brawler. Boxer. Drinker. War hero. Ladies' male. Even for his period, Ernest Hemingway was masculinity in hyperbole. The outsized writer of stripped-back prose was also, a novel documentary argues, an explorer of gender fluidity in the bedroom – both in his literature and his life. At a cultural moment which favours simplistic interpretations of iconic figures as villains or heroes, American filmmakers Ken Burns and Lynn Novick muddy the waters of the fallen literary famous person in Hemingway, their non-hagiographic, six-hour examination of the contradiction between the myth and the man.
“For us it's about making things more complex,” Burns tells me, on a contact from his home in Walpole, New Hampshire. “Hemingway is monstrous at times and there's never a moment in the movie where we let him off the hook.” The writer’s epic and, ultimately, tragic life allowed him to create literature – considered to be among the most influential in the English language – that Burns says
Ernest Hemingway's Sexuality Remains a Subject of Speculation Decades After His Death
When Ernest Hemingway died, he left behind literary works that would be read, renowned, and examined for years. And, although most still admire him for his work, others still hold curiosities about Hemingway's sexuality and whether he was, in fact, gay. Hemingway himself never openly identified as gay during his life, but for some scholars, the proof was in many of his books.
Article continues below advertisement
While it's never a great idea to speculate about someone's sexuality, Hemingway's experience and reputed personality paved the way for many to wonder about him long after his death. The PBS documentary Hemingway explores his personal experience and relationships, of which he had many. Now, people have even more questions about him.
Article continues below advertisement
Was Ernest Hemingway gay?
Hemingway never "came out," in any sense of the phrase, but there are still many who assume he might own been gay, or simply identified as having been sexuality fluid. Queerness, as a concept, came after his time, because when he was alive, it wasn't common for a man to
.